Fact Checker: Is it training, or is it torture?

Democracy Dies in Darkness
	The truth behind the rhetoric

Is it training, or is it torture? Torture is back in the news because President Trump’s nominee to lead the CIA is Gina Haspel, a veteran intelligence official who once ran a black site prison in Thailand and was involved in the decision to destroy videotapes showing the waterboarding of al-Qaeda members during the George W. Bush administration. Talking about the “enhanced interrogation techniques” of the Bush years —and whether they achieved results — is a lot like talking about religion. Either you believe it or you don’t, and there is little bridging the chasm. Rep. Liz Cheney is a believer. She says these techniques did work, and she argues they are not unlike what you would see in Survival, Evasion, Resistance, and Escape, a program that helps train U.S. military personnel in survival techniques in case they are captured by an enemy. But these two programs do not have the same purpose: one aimed to extract information from detainees, the other to build endurance for U.S. military personnel in worst-case scenarios. Enjoy this newsletter? Forward it to someone else who’d like it! If this e-mail was forwarded to you, sign up here for the weekly newsletter. Hear something fact-checkable? Send it here, we’ll check it out. Houston, we have a problem with this claim from Trump Trump has racked up his fair share of Pinocchios for all kinds of statements involving Planet Earth. But one of his recent claims was out of this world. Trump said that Americans would not be going to Mars, and that people wouldn’t even be thinking about it, had Hillary Clinton won the presidency. Well, Clinton has been talking about getting humans to Mars since at least 1999. In the 2016 race, she specifically supported plans to get humans on the Red Planet one day. She visited a factory making parts for the NASA rocket being built for the interplanetary trip. And it’s not like Trump started NASA’s efforts to go to Mars. The space agency has been planning a “Journey to Mars” for years, with continuity throughout different administrations. Clinton in all likelihood would have continued those efforts, just as Trump has. Like an asteroid hit by a comet, Trump’s claim quickly disintegrated under scrutiny, and we gave him Four Pinocchios.

President Trump’s claim that drug dealers who kill ‘thousands’ just get 30 days in jail The president ends up in Four-Pinocchio territory because of the way he frames his rhetoric. By Glenn Kessler  •   Read more »  President Trump’s false claim that Clinton wouldn’t have sent humans to Mars The president spaced out while describing Clinton's position on Mars exploration. By Salvador Rizzo  •   Read more »  President Trump’s claim that California has the ‘highest taxes in the United States’ Many readers from California complained that the president is way out of line in criticizing their tax burden. By Glenn Kessler  •   Read more »  Questions raised about study that links undocumented immigrants to higher crime We look at a controversial study that found undocumented immigrants bring higher crime. Do its numbers add up? By Salvador Rizzo  •   Read more »  The harsh interrogations of al-Qaeda detainees: Was it ‘torture’ and did it help find bin Laden? Each side picks and chooses facts in order to make their case. Here's a guide to the torture debate. By Glenn Kessler  •   Read more »  Fact-checking Trump’s error-filled tweetstorm about the Mueller probe The president attacked the Russian investigation and the FBI in a series of tweets, but his claims were often misleading or wrong. By Glenn Kessler  •   Read more »